Migraine Fact or Fiction?

Published by

on

Earlier this year, the Migraine World Summit was held for 2025. Β This year there were again, several presentations from a variety of people, mostly doctors and researchers, updating the audience on the latest in migraine understanding.Β  I confess this year was a little disappointing given so much of the material was placed behind a paywall.Β  The 30-minute videos that were available for free, for example, chewed up a lot of time introducing, advertising, then farewelling the presenter and their subject, so there was really only 20 minutes of advice per episode.Β  That said, there still was some really interesting material which I’ll summarize over the next few months.

Perhaps one of the simplest but most interesting presentations I watched was the one in which Dr Thomas Berk ran through the reality of strange treatment options, and what tends to work (and what doesn’t) when it comes to treating migraine pain.

The interview started with a general introduction, noting that many β€œcures” are circulating the internet, including placing cold peas on your neck whilst your feet are in hot water (I’ve written about it before here), or putting raw onion on your forehead (!?).  Dr Berk noted that this sort of information can trivialize the pain that migraine patients suffer, because it doesn’t recognize the reality of how hard it can be to budge the pain, and it can make you feel guilty that you aren’t able to simply help yourself out of the situation and hurry up and heal.

Whilst acknowledging that there’s no shame in saying you’ll β€œtry anything” to get better (I nearly had the palate of my mouth massaged – but my gag reflex was too strong!), he noted that many of the β€œsolutions” online were not helpful, scientific, or based on medical advice.  Even more subtly, he noted that not all doctors are created equal.  Whilst they might be trying to help, not all of them specialize in migraines, so even highly trained practitioners (chiros and physios etc) might not understand some of the underlying biological aspects of migraine.  He even went so far as to suggest the average general practitioner receives only a small amount of headache-related training at university, and as such, many are using out-of-date advice when treating their patients.

Dr Berk’s main advice on whether to follow the suggestions of people online is to check their qualifications first, be skeptical if they receive financial kickbacks from selling other people’s products or are touting their supplements as the ONLY solution, look for testimonials, or better yet, scientific data to back up their claims.Β  Whilst there can’t be randomized control trials for every possible migraine approach, many reputable approaches HAVE been tested – so check if the proposed solution is one of them.Β 

Lastly – trust your intuition… does this REALLY make sense to you???   

That said, Dr Berk acknowledged the mind is a powerful thing.  The β€œplacebo effect” is real.  Some people can heal because they believe they are being treated in a way which will allow them to heal.  Perhaps hope alone can reduce stress and improve the vagal nerve condition, which in turn might reduce migraine pain.

When asked what his pet peeve migraine-hack was, Dr Berk replied β€œputting your feet in hot water” – whilst it is a comforting thing to do, the vascular theory of blood vessels getting dilated and pulling blood from your head to your feet is a 25+ years out-of-date approach to migraines. We now believe that migraines are an inflammatory condition that can cause dilation in the brain, but tricks with hot water are no longer supported by science.

[Disclaimer – this is a good place to remind you I am not a doctor or researcher – I am only repeating my own understanding of what I discover – please speak to a trained professional to make sure that you get the right advice, relative to your own unique condition.]

Perhaps one of the most interesting asides, was potentially also the riskiest to share.  Dr Berk and the interviewer discussed if there was such a thing as a β€œmigraine cocktail” that could be used to break a particular nasty migraine attack.  He replied that a combination of magnesium, electrolytes, antihistamines and anti-inflammatories could help.  He mentioned some brand names, but they were probably from the USA as I didn’t recognize any of them – sorry.  He also wasn’t clear about dosages, or whether you take them all at once or in a particular sequence.

[Disclaimer – AGAIN – don’t follow medical advice from anyone other than your own doctor who knows the details of your condition and the other medications that you are currently taking, as mixing medicine can have negative consequences.]

In terms of general over the counter things that could help, Dr Berk suggested aromatherapy (lavender and peppermint) because it helps with inflammation and is soothing.  Ice-caps worked for some people, not, he said, because they shrink blood cells or change blood flow, but because they acted as a distraction through the new sensation.  Topical muscle-creams helped for a similar reason.  And lasty, ginger for nausea is another option.

The interviewer then ran through a list of treatment suggestions that are often floating around and asked Dr Berk to give a 0 to 3 rating for each one, with 0 being no help at all, and 3 suggesting there was some truth to it being useful in reducing migraine pain.Β  I’ve reordered the answers from 3 to 0 to give some clarity to the list:

  • Bio-feedback – 3 – low risk with great evidence it helps through guided breathing, meditation, relaxing, reduced heart rate – highly recommended as a treatment option.
  • Antihistamines – 3 – helps, but be careful about other conditions, and don’t try to drive a car after taking the tablets [um… hello… can I suggest you shouldn’t be driving a car whilst suffering a migraine attack?!?]
  • Blue light filters – 3 – we know that blue light upsets migraine patients, so orange lenses can help – but make sure they are real glasses, not just tinted plastic lenses.  Alternatively, look at using screen protectors, or adjusting the setting on your devices.
  • Ginger – 2/3 – if you can tolerate it, it can be helpful combatting nausea.
  • Cola – 2 – helps and doesn’t hurt – used for hydration and caffeine (so long as you aren’t having extra caffeine elsewhere as too much can trigger / worsen a migraine.)
  • Motion sickness wristbands – 2 – there is some anecdotal evidence that the acupressure helps the vagal tone, and there is no harm trying.
  • Menthol gel – 2 – it does have some anti-inflammatory value, and the spearmint essential oils they often use can help from an aromatherapy point of view.
  • Salty food – 2 – eating during an attack is not as helpful as drinking due to nausea.  Getting the salt via electrolyte drinks is a preferable approach, but yes, salt can help.
  • Massage – 2 – this can help those with muscle tension and can help relax you overall and encourage deep breathing, however it’s not for everyone and sometimes issues such as pinched nerves are the cause of the migraine and massage may make it worse.
  • TENS units – 2 – Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation units can help people who have muscle-tension related migraines.  For many people, it acts as a form of massage.
  • Daith piercing – 1 – looks cool and may make you feel better, but there is no science behind it.
  • Ear seeds – 0/1 – without knowing for certain what chemicals or hormones are in them, they could cause more harm than good.

So then, any last comments? Β Β A couple.Β  One is, if your friends and family offer advice which sounds a bit dodgy to you, (but you know it’s coming from a place of care and concern), then reply β€œthanks, I’ll mention it to my doctor” and then follow it up with your doctor if you’re interested.Β  Dr Berk also reminded the listeners that misinformation is everywhere.Β  Social media is a tricky place to look for answers to something as complex as migraines. Β As a minimum, consider hanging out in migraine community chats (or blogs!) where real people with real lived experience are comparing notes.Β  Your best bet, however, is to listen to doctors who specialize in headaches and migraines; β€œthere’s rarely anything NEW out there, so we can tell you about what exists and what is likely to work for you.”

Lots to think about.

[If you’re curious about which items on the solution list I’ve tried and am a fan of: ginger and menthol gel are my go-to items on this list, and mindfulness is my version of biofeedback.]

Take care taking care people, and know that I’m sending love, whether you’re wearing an ice-cap or a piece of raw onion on your forehead, you do you (safely),

Linda xox

PS – You can read more about migraine misconceptions over on Neurahealth.co with Dr Berk discussing the issue with Migraine Meanderings a year ago: Dispelling Migraine Myths: Insights from Dr. Thomas Berk’s Conversation with Migraine Meanderings.

PPS – One of the first blog posts I ever wrote was about receiving (un)solicited advice for migraines and how you can imagine yourself as either a β€˜spongey-camel’ or a β€˜colander-duck’: https://themindfulmigraine.blog/2024/02/19/unsolicited-advice-for-migraines/


Discover more from The Mindful Migraine

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

29 responses to “Migraine Fact or Fiction?”

  1. Brain freeze and migraines – The Mindful Migraine Avatar

    […] I wrote about a neurologist who debunked the whole ‘blood vessels cause migraines’ approach a while ago (“Migraine fact or fiction“). […]

    Like

  2. Worshiping false idols – The Mindful Migraine Avatar

    […] while back, I did a post on Migraine Facts and Fiction summarizing a neurologist’s beliefs. Many of the “helpful” items on his list were […]

    Like

  3. What is the Alexander Technique? – The Mindful Migraine Avatar

    […] Summit, one of the doctors gave a “fact or fiction” presentation (which I wrote about here) and suggested constricted blood vessels to the brain was an out-of-date explanation for migraines. […]

    Like

  4. Does mustard help migraines?!? – The Mindful Migraine Avatar

    […] Several believed just having your feet in warm water whilst also having a cold compress on the back of your neck to redistribute blood flow was a winner, and as such, you could “give the hotdog garnish a miss”. (I’ve blogged about the super hottie / cool kid aspect of migraines before (here) AND I’ve posted that this exact hack is a pet peeve of Dr Berk and why (here)). […]

    Like

  5. Do ear seeds help migraines? – The Mindful Migraine Avatar

    […] while ago I posted notes from an interview I heard with Dr Berk about migraine facts and fiction (here). During the interview, I heard mention of something completely new (to me): “ear […]

    Like

  6. pk 🌎 Avatar

    Great post πŸ’“πŸ΅οΈπŸŒ·

    Happy afternoon β˜€οΈπŸŒŽπŸ‡ͺπŸ‡¦

    God bless you 🌈

    Liked by 1 person

    1. The Mindful Migraine Blog Avatar

      Wow! You’ve been a busy reader today! Thank you! Xx

      Like

  7. silverapplequeen Avatar

    Blue lights upset people with migraines? Really? I have blue lights all over my house! I don’t believe that for a minute ~ at least not for me. A string hanging in my front windows, a string hanging in the archway in the dining room & a string over the windows in my study that’s supposed to look like water flowing ~ because I wanted to live near water & that didn’t happen ~ although with all this rain we’re having, my back yard is turning into a lake!

    What seems to be working for me is the combination of B-complex, CoQ-10 & Magnesium. I just upped the CoQ-10 to 200 mg a day ~ 100 in the morning & 100 in the afternoon. CoQ-10 is expensive but I found a store that has a less expensive brand. & what isn’t expensive nowadays? Ya know?

    I don’t think doctors know a thing other than what they learned in college. & most of them learned enough to pass their tests & get their degrees so they could get a job ~ at least here in the US. Most of them just want to write a few scripts & get you out of the office so they can see the next patient & do the same thing. Where I go, the name of the game is to get you to have BOTOX injections, which I did have for many years ~ which DID work ~ it was a real game changer ~ until it didn’t work anymore. The thing about BOTOX is that it’s a bacterial toxin & your body produces antibodies to fight this ~ as it should! ~ so eventually this “cure” doesn’t work anymore. This is also why people who get BOTOX for cosmetic reasons eventually look like hell ~ worse than they would have naturally ~ because it doesn’t work anymore!

    I noticed that my doctor has really lost interest in me since I said I didn’t want to get the BOTOX injections anymore. I’m not a cash cow anymore.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. The Mindful Migraine Blog Avatar

      I feel very conflicted about Botox – I started it about a year and a half ago and for my migraines, and it DID make a difference (although I started it at the same time I started mindfulness). The more research I do into it though, the queasier I feel – like you said, it’s a toxin and can slowly build up in your body. Now that I’m feeling a lot better and my migraines are getting down to a couple a month instead of almost every day, I’m thinking of weaning myself off the Botox by going from 3 month injections to 4 to 5…. but at the same time I suggested it to my doctor, he suggested I do the reverse and get extra injections in my jaw to reduce my teeth grinding… sigh… in Australia it is partially covered by insurance, but it is still a big out of pocket expense.

      As for the CoQ10, I got weak kneed at the cost last time I picked up a bottle, but I’m hearing so much good news about it, I’m thinking I might start up – you’re right – everything costs a lot these days – but our health really ought to be a priority… what was that old ad… “I’m worth it”!

      Like

  8.  Avatar
    Anonymous

    reducing stress is the very best answer in my book, tell that to our very fast moving world πŸ€·β€β™€οΈ

    Liked by 1 person

    1. The Mindful Migraine Blog Avatar

      You are SO right – about the need to reduce stress as a game changer in our healing – AND about it being so tricky to do in the world we find ourselves in. I try to do it in small increments – a few minutes here and there a day – a session of deep breathing, a few minutes later in the day of a body-scan, a warm shower another time… they are small investments that seem to add up… but yes, it is a bit like putting your fingers in the cracks of a dam wall that is about to burst! Sending love and healing vibes; we got this! L xx

      Like

  9. justrojie Avatar

    Fab information! Some of these I am familiar with and I’d like to see since migraines are due to inflammation, I wonder how gluten or wheat allergies could play a factor into this as well.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. The Mindful Migraine Blog Avatar

      I’m not a food allergy person (I’ve been lucky like that) – but I have read a lot of anecdotal evidence that gluten is an issue for some people, I think it’s why the KETO diet, which is low in gluten, might help reduce migraine attacks. I haven’t tried the diet myself, as someone once referred to it as the sort of diet you have to marry rather than date – it takes a lot of commitment to get it right. Good luck on your journey, wheat-free or otherwise! L xx

      Liked by 1 person

      1. justrojie Avatar

        Thank you!!

        Liked by 1 person

        1. The Mindful Migraine Blog Avatar

          🀩

          Liked by 1 person

      2. silverapplequeen Avatar

        I went to an allergist about 10 years ago & went through a battery of tests & found out I’m allergic to everything EXCEPT food. LOL

        Liked by 1 person

        1. The Mindful Migraine Blog Avatar

          🀣I shouldn’t laugh but I think I’m the same – dust, grass, latex, etc all make me itchy, but food… food I can tolerate! (except alcohol – that literally blows my mind – and gives me a migraine!) Enjoy the sweet tastes the world has to offer – you deserve it! L xx

          Like

  10. The Oceanside Animals Avatar

    Lulu: “I don’t know about most of those treatments, but I like belly rubs. Does that count as a massage?”

    Liked by 1 person

    1. The Mindful Migraine Blog Avatar

      Ummm… yes… if you’re a cat or a dog like you Lulu – if you’re human like me, it gets harder to define the medical benefits (although I’m sure there are some!) [blush]

      Like

  11. James Viscosi Avatar

    I never heard of “daith piercing” so I looked it up and now my ear hurts. 😁 The TENS treatments have come up a few times in my aneurysm group where people with clips (some of which are affected by magnets) are wondering if they can get it safely, and the answer seems to be, “Maybe?”

    Liked by 1 person

    1. The Mindful Migraine Blog Avatar

      So, I tried someone else’s TENS device a while back and – yuck – I didn’t like it at all. Instead of feeling like a massage, like Dr Berk said, I felt it as a weird below-surface pulse which felt very foreign – the opposite of a gentle surface massage in fact. Others I know swear by them… but only for migraines – I would definitely be getting extra advice before trying one for any other brain condition, especially since “Maybe” doesn’t sound like a convincing sign off to me! Like I said though, I don’t feel like I’m missing out on anything by not using it. L xx

      Like

  12. joannerambling Avatar

    As I read this I kept thing about how some not so nice people will try and sell those suffering any old rot just to make money off their pain, yes there are some good natural treatments around, for most part it can be hit or miss

    Liked by 1 person

    1. The Mindful Migraine Blog Avatar

      I like the idea that great-grandma knew best, and old fashioned remedies can still work (like ginger)… although migraines are generally super-stubborn and often resistant to anything but modern meds.

      Like you, my blood boils when it seems like people are profiteering off other people’s misfortunes. Everyone has to make a living, I get that, but it seems a bit wrong if you’re using pushy scare tactics on unwell people. YUK.

      Like

  13. LaDonna Remy Avatar

    Thank you, Linda. I appreciated this article; I like the idea of natural remedies (ginger and menthol) and
    the information by Dr Berk.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. The Mindful Migraine Blog Avatar

      You’re super welcome – it’s nice to know there are still some natural things we can do (but for me – when the migraine is really at its worst – it has to be medicine!) I was thinking about it some more last night and realized they never rated the raw onion on the head! Have a wonderful day, Linda xx

      Liked by 1 person

      1. LaDonna Remy Avatar

        πŸ™‚ I do think it’s important to take those steps.

        Liked by 1 person

        1. The Mindful Migraine Blog Avatar

          πŸ₯°

          Liked by 1 person

  14. Michael Williams Avatar

    great post Linda. you know, i like being able to take naproxen for my headaches but I know there is a trade-off for it concerning my liver. these days, the only thing I can do is contain the sources/behaviors that cause it. I don’t have them often but when I do they can really ruin my entire day and I often wish there just ways to attack it where there wasn’t too big of a tradeoff with your liver or your heart or your pancreas. again, great post! I also do menthol gel and ginger is a very underrated ingredient for overall health! Mike

    Liked by 2 people

    1. The Mindful Migraine Blog Avatar

      Yay – welcome to the ginger-menthol club! And yes, so much of healing seems to be a series of trade-offs, but like you, concentrating on reducing the stressors and triggers so we can avoid the headache in the first place seems to be the way to go (where possible). May today be as painless as possible, L xx

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply to James Viscosi Cancel reply